This content has been archived. It may no longer be relevant
Fearmongering about China’s growing power in the world is a common pastime in foreign policy circles and particularly popular among white, middle-aged, male IR scholars who need a quick ‘academic’ best-seller that will make the review list of Foreign Affairs or even The Economist. True, Chinese politics and society is so large, big and varied that it offers numerous clichés of danger that can be easily mobilised. Only recently, the Australian investigative journalism programme ‘4 corners’ managed to stitch together such a patchwork. Everything was there: dodgy Chinese businessmen buying off huge chunks of Australia’s public services, pretty but ruthless Chinese businesswomen playing matchmaker between corrupt politicians and Chinese secret services, heavily brainwashed and surveilled Chinese students being paid for waving flags in front of the Chinese embassy in Canberra, upright and heroic, if somewhat naive Australian-Chinese exilees fighting for democracy and human rights, greedy and not very intelligent young Chinese buying houses in prime locations with money nobody knows where it came from, outdated scholars and politicians being bought into an empty-shell research institute to legitimate China’s presence in Australia, and many more tropes of current Australian China fears. To be sure, nothing that the 4 corners reported showed was wrong or ‘fake news’! Dodgy Chinese businessmen with close relations to the Communist Party are buying off huge chunks of Australia’s public services, Chinese students are often nationalistic to a point that seems extreme, Chinese everywhere in the world who express their sympathies for democracy, civic and human rights are closely surveilled by the Chinese state and the real estate market in Australia most certainly serves to exfiltrate money from China (keeping in mind that China exercises strict currency control that does not allow common citizens to invest abroad). Yet, the degree to which all this needs to be feared as a coordinated attack on Australia’s (or any other country’s) freedom remains an open question. Presented all together it would appear as if there was a little office somewhere in the Beijing’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs with Australia’s map on the wall. I would imagine three spectacled (don’t they all wear glasses?), crop haired Chinese men standing in front of this map with little flags. ‘Ha! And we’re buying all their cherries, too!’ — triumphantly planting a little flag right into the center of the Huon valley!
Once these stories are looked at from a closer range and de-orientalized, they most often lose their scariness and rather reveal the double standards with which Chinese people, politics and society are measured. As all good orientalist stereotypes the anti-China fears work well because the precisely cover up the weaknesses of our Western democracies. If China’s wrong-doings are painted in glaring light, they will overshine ours. China violates human and civil rights in Tibet and Xinjiang? Well, ask indigenous people in Australia, Canada, USA or other places in America what they think about Western democracies respect for human and civil rights. China persecutes dissidents? Well, what do white Americans think of Black Live Matters? China is a high-surveillance state? Well, they did not invent biometric data identification; the Americans did. They were not even the first to follow the USA, the Europeans were there before. China abuses the rights and livelihoods of millions of migrant workers? Well, how many people die daily crossing the Mediterranean? The list could go on. None of this is to be apologetic about China, or Western democracy. Violations of human rights, human dignity and integrity are violations of human rights, human dignity and integrity everywhere. The point is: if ‘we’, white middle-class people in Western democracies need not fear, let’s say the Australian government despite their appalling record of violating the civil and human rights of indigenous people and refugees, why should ‘we’ fear China? Once the double standards are replaced with only one ‘normalized’ standard of human cruelty and power abuse, then what’s there to fear that we have not already produced in our Western democracies?