This content has been archived. It may no longer be relevant
For those teaching international relations, the past two years have been troubling times. The rise of ethno-nationalism as well as the xenophobic and anti-globalist retraction of politics that we have seen in the UK’s Brexit campaign and politics, and in the election of the President of the United States have grossly exaggerated what is wrong with the current world order. Feminist, queer and post-colonial international relations work have since long pointed out the asymmetries, inequalities, fault lines, exploitations and injustices of the so-called liberal world order. If we want to understand how we got to the current crisis it is well worth looking deep into these analyses.
Feminizing and decolonizing readings lists, hence, does not mean to add a couple of female and non-Western names to the reading list but requires a rethinking of the way we teach the ‘classics’, i.e. courses on international security, international organisations/cooperation, introductions to international relations, IR theories etc.
For both my classes, International Security and International Cooperation at UTAS, I chose to go back in history. We have come to think that nationalism and the building of sovereign nation-states has been an achievement against imperialism and imperial reason — decolonization having been all too often a bloody affair and the sacrifices of these struggles should be honoured by acknowledging the defeat of imperialism. And yet…the persistence of categorical inequalities and injustices in this world suggests that the exploitative global structures of imperialism did not vanish with the independence of former colonies. What did change, however, were the stories we were told and that we continue to tell our students in mainstream IR. Looking for instance at the enthusiasm 1990s institutionalists had for Europe’s 19th century concert diplomacy, it is remarkable that they do not even mention that European great power rivalry was displaced from Europe to the colonial empires. In order to decolonize and feminize reading lists we also need to think about telling new and different stories about the ways the current world order came into being and how it works.
These narratives then need to be framed in the terms that feminist and decolonial/postcolonial scholars have developed and established. Being a female scholar is not yet a sufficient quality to make it on the reading list of a feminized and decolonized reading list, since, clearly, there are far too many female scholars who fully support the malestream theoretical narratives of world order (you know the USA being the beacon of liberal hopes, human rights and all, and international institutions following, or should be/could be following, their lightning lead of promoting welfare, human rights, peace and so on, yaddayaddayadda).
A brilliant start to think about the changes we need to make to the way we present and think the world, and its politics is Gurminder Bhambra’s Connected Sociologies. Bhambra provides an excellent overview over the problematic implications of explaining world order in terms of global modernity such as Neo-Weberian (although they might be better called Neo-How-Parsons-Tranlated-Weberian), world system, or multiple modernity approaches. She cogently points out that their problem is not only their inherent eurocentric epistemology, notably with using the notion of ‘modernity’ per se, but also in their ontology of what is seen as relevant world politics (i.e. state politics) or global-social structures. She then proceeds to discussing alternative approaches such as cosmopolitanism (dissolving the state perspective), indigenous approaches (moving away from state and even human centred understandings of politics, community, relations etc.) and decolonial thinking (moving away from linear progressive discourses of modernity and development). By doing so, Bhambra articulates very clearly her argument for focussing on connections and what might be called contingencies in the historical movements of global societies and their interactions and connections. The crucial point of Bhambra’s argument is that a properly decolonized global sociology is preoccupied not with showing that quasi-state structures or other ‘elements of modernity’ existed also in Chinese, Ashanti, Inka, Maori or otherwise colonized histories but that their existence and destruction were