Geopolitics, Peace and war, USA, World Politics

How the Nobel Peace committee squandered the Peace Nobel Prize’s legacy

The Nobel Peace Prize exists since 1901. Legend has it that it was created by Alfred Nobel after a serious talking to by his friend Bertha von Suttner, the Austrian feminist and pacificist who was also the fourth, and first female recipient of the price in 1905. The very first Nobel Peace Prize was awarded to Henri Dunant for the foundation of the Red Cross. Whether the Peace Price was really an homage to von Suttner and their friendship, Alfred Nobel’s intentions were clear not only from the remit of the Nobel Foundation but also its first recipients: to honour efforts to reign in warmaking through international law and the reinforcement of humanist norms in the interactions of states. The protection of human digntiy and lives through the promotion of international law and diplomacy were at the centre of Nobel’s intentions as he wrote In his will: “one part (of the foundations funds should go) to the person who has done the most or best to advance fellowship among nations, the abolition or reduction of standing armies, and the establishment and promotion of peace congresses”.

The large majority of awardees in the early years reflected the work and optimism of organisations, lawyers and politicians of international law that this newly emerging corpus of norms and rules would reign in militarism and hold the international actors to commonly agree and respected standards of humanist behaviour in war and diplomacy.

Of course, only European or European origin countries counted as ‘international actors’ with very few, notable exceptions (like Japan). The two thirds of the world that were subdued to imperial colonialism were, by definition, excluded from the ‘international’. And of course, only European or ‘Western’ men were at any time in the realm of those considered for the price. Thus, Mahatma Gandhi for instance was never awarded the Nobel Peace Price although he had been nominated a rough dozen times. Since 1901 only nine women have received the price and of these four had to share the price with others. Jane Addams, the American suffragette and peace activist, had been nominated 38 times, shortlisted six times before she received the price in 1931.

Yet, in the past twenty, thirty years, the Nobel Peace Prize Committee has definitely aimed at using their platform and the award’s prestige to support individuals and organisations who have worked for both, the Eurocentric humanist values of universal human rights and democracy, and the rights and sovereignty of former colonies and the global South.

So, it seems that with the 2025 award to Maria Corina Machado from Venezuela the Committee had bravely ticked two boxes of changing the original legacy of the Peace Prize: an awardee from the Global South and a woman – a striking difference to the first 70 or so years of the foundation rewarding mainly men, and mainly white men from the global North. But no, this impression is wrong. In fact, they have squandered the Nobel legacy, big time! And not only because in act of utterly debile sycophancy, Machado has given the medal to Trump as a gift for ‘freeing Venezuela’.

The non-sense of this entire drama cannot be over-emphasized. A president whose administration’s death toll is rising by the day and who is squashing democracy, rule of law and human rights in his own country and abroad; said president threatens the country of Norway so massively that the intimidated Nobel Peace Prize Committee thinks it is a brilliant idea to give the prize to a person they assume is allied to Trump, a right-wing, ever-Trumper whose main motivation is to gain power in Venezuela to revert the nationalisation of her family’s riches; and who then, just in the very moment where the President is threatening its NATO partners with war over Greenland (!) decides to bribe her way into the favours of the man who ultimately is responsible for the illegal killing of sailors in the Caribbean and the totally, utterly illegal military attack on her own country! And the committee meekly saying that the prize cannot be transferred to another person.

What a buyer’s regret and hangover the Nobel Peace Prize committee members must feel now! Yet, their decision was from the outset flawed and the award to Machado undeserved. Sure, Machado was deprived illegitimately and illegally from her election victory. Sure, she was persecuted and lived in hiding. But that alone does not make her an epigone of democracy, human rights and humanism. And this was also not what made her so attractive to the Nobel Prize committee. The list of nominations is published only decades after the award; yet, it is implausible that there were not other nominations of people who genuinely work for the values expressed in Alfred Nobel’s testament, and under probably far less favourable circumstances as Machado who might be politically persecuted but estimated to have an annual income somewhere between US$630,000 and US$865,000.

What made Machado palpable as prize awardee was precisely her connection to Trump. The decision was one of those half-baked ‘compromises’ between the yielding to the relentless aggressive trolling power of the US administration and affirming the committee’s (and Norway’s) independence. Whoever put Machado’s name on the list and on top must have felt very smart, indeed. Yet, just as all other institutions that yielded to Trump’s bullying, they only betrayed their foundational values and got another slap in the face anyway; expertly and tackily delivered by the awardee herself.

Awarding the prize to Machado was a mistake from the beginning; now it would be time to acknowledge this mistake and to recall the award. Simple as that. Machado did not deserve the prize in the first place and she has definitely shown absolutely no respect for the its significance, legacy or history. The Nobel Peace Prize Committee has in awarding it to this goon squad of pseudo-fascist grifters squandered the price’s prestige.